Since this is the last newsletter for 2012, it might be time to consider
what we might wish for in 2013, those of us with an interest in all things
nautical, and more importantly those of us still out there doing the job. So
here are a few possible wishes in no particular order.
It is surely time that the IMO got a grip of ship registries. If a country
wishes to host a registry they should be able to demonstrate the necessary
expertise and organization which would enable them to train seafarers,
examine them and award certificates of competency and not least carry out
investigations into accidents.
I know we keep talking about it, but could we possibly make some progress
towards treating shipmasters who have had the misfortune to be involved in
groundings resulting in pollution in a responsible manner, and stop
immediately accusing them of being criminals.
Could we review the relationship between the ship-owner and class. Is it
right that the insurers of ships rely on the inspection processes carried
out by the classification societies who are paid by the ship-owners? Hence
of the ship-owner does not like what class are doing they can find
Could we start to get real about risk assessments, and start to make them
meaningful, ie, a means of keeping people alive and uninjured, rather than a
means of arse-covering.
I realize that I could go on. There are many lesser wishes, which might help
seafarers enjoy a relatively untroubled life, most of them to do with asking
ship-owners to act responsibly, and while many do, there are probably more
who do not, so we don’t have a level playing field.
ANOTHER WISH / SOME SORT OF CONTROL OVER THE PIRATE PROBLEM
I have a look at the
MARITIME BULLETIN on occasion, which is edited by Voytenko Mikhail and is in
the main informed by the misfortunes of Russian seafarers. Sadly it is
shutting down due to lack of financial support, but if it is able to
continue there will be more stories of piracy on both sides of Africa. Last
week his website published the story of the Myre Seadiver, a vessel manned
by a private Russian security service, which has been arrested by the
Nigerian authorities. The editor suggests that the reason is that it is a
real security service, and has proved to be competition for the local
services. Of course it is no competition at all while it is held in port,
its situation for the last two months.
This winter vomiting virus
is very unpleasant, and that’s even if you’re just reading about it. There
is nothing worse that large numbers of people in a confined space who are
unable to control their bodily functions. Hence the photo of the Oriana
which made the news last week because over 400 passengers were suffering
from the Norovirus, and their whole cruise and that of other passengers, one
assumes, was spoilt.
I clicked on a link in Google and was taken to the Daily Mail website, now
becoming notorious for its sensationalist approach to the news. So it was no
surprise that the article included a photo of the Captain smiling at us over
the telegraphs, probably taken on a happier day, but more surprising that at
least one of the readers comments seemed to be directed personally at him. I
don’t do Twitter, but I suppose if you do you must get used to people
directing comments at you.
A couple of days ago the ship was preparing for a new 23 day Mediterranean
cruise, and it made the news again. This time because during the cleaning of
the ship, to eradicate the remains of the virus “the disabled passengers
were left for hours in the terminal”. They really can’t win can they? And
finally we have to remember that even the largest liners are still ships at
sea. As usual we could say more!!
THE VOS SAILOR
The VOS Sailor when it was the Dea Sailor in 2004
As we go to press (I’ve always wanted to use this phrase) the unfortunate
VOS Sailor is being towed towards the North east coast of Scotland after
being disabled in rough seas. The crew of the North Sea Producer an FPSO
were evacuated to other installations as the drifting vessel threatened to
collide with it.
At present the news about the accident is scanty, we only know that the ship
was swamped by a large wave in high winds, and that one crew member lost his
life. The reports say “sustained fatal injuries” so it may be that when the
wave came aboard he was caught in its path in some way.
The eleven remaining crew members were winched onto a a Bond Jigsaw
helicopter*, and the winchman apparently sustained injuries to one foot
while remaining on board to supervise the rescue of the crew.
If you look at the photograph of this vessel it may occur to you that this
little ship appears to be unsuited to the task of going out into the
Northern North Sea, and standing by some sort of installation which would
appear to be better equipped for the environment that the ship itself. So it
may be appropriate to look briefly at the history of the ERRV – or standby
boat as they used to be known.
It was the loss of the Sea Gem in 1965 which resulted in the requirement
that offshore installations of all sorts should be provided with a standby
boat, and as offshore oil exploration increased the fishing industry
provided the service using retired trawlers – side draggers – as they were
known. These old ships were seaworthy, but ill suited to the task, mainly
due to the lack of maneuvering capability. However, nothing changed until
Piper Alpha (25 years ago next year) when the standby vessel Silver Pit,
another side dragger, proved itself to have limited capability to take its
part in the rescue. The ship was then 40 years old.
Lord Cullen said “I am entirely satisfied that in the above respects (Maneuvering
capability) the Silver Pit was essentially unsuitable for the purpose of
effecting the rescue of survivors”.
The code which was developed subsequent to Piper Alpha required among other
things that standby boats should be provided with “a single screw and
azimuthing thruster capable of producing a speed of four knots in the ahead
direction or twin screw propulsion and a side thruster”.
The result of these requirements was that in addition to the traditional
providers of standby vessels, usually former fishing fleet owners, a number
of support vessel owners decided to get into the business either using older
units from their own fleets or else going out into the world to find
suitable second hand craft.
At least one owner specialized in checking out the bayous in Louisiana for
suitable hulls, and brought over to Europe a number of traditional North
American ships, had the necessary additional accommodation added on the deck
and put them to work. Others used old Norwegian and British anchor-handlers,
similarly putting accommodation on the afterdeck, adding the rescue craft
and sending them to sea. The VOS Sailor and its sister ship the VOS Scout
were built in Vancouver in 1981 as the Canmar Wigeon and the Canmar Teal,
and were discovered by a Sealion superintendent laid up in the ice in Canada
in 1991. Of course they met the essential requirements of the new standby
vessel legislation. If one looks at their specification one might doubt that
a 100 bhp bow thruster is powerful enough and wonder whether the 1700 bhp
developed by the main engines is adequate, but this is in the light of our
experience with much more powerful ships today.
So on the face of it, it seems surprising that there have not been more
accidents to standby vessels (ERRVs) out there, and this must be in part due
to the experience of those on board them, and the fact that in general if
you are not trying to get anywhere quite small ships remain safe in extreme
weather. But this is not always true. I was once mate of an anchor handler
which was dodging (just hanging about on station) in extreme weather, when a
wave pushed in one of the bridge windows. The only system left to us was the
steering, and just as well. We ran before the sea for a day while filling in
the hole with an engine room plate.
The good news in this rather bleak situation is that the oil companies and
standby vessel owners are gradually replacing the old tonnage with new
ships. Indeed Vroon, the owners of the VOS Sailor are building new ships,
and scrapping the very old supply boats in the fleet at such a rate that it
is difficult to keep up with them.
*There is more about the Bond helicopters on the website.
Island Enforcer photos from the Island Offshore website.
The recent failings of the
Super Puma EC225 helicopter, on one occasion resulting in the deaths of 16
people, have resulted in extensive “reinstatement” of the type. In turn,
this has given the personnel departments of the oil companies problems as
they have attempted to maintain their crew change schedules.
Hence we have seen a return to the use of the “personnel transfer device” ,
moving people to and from offshore installations to and from ships. The
Island Enforcer, for instance has been hired by Talisman to carry out
transfers from Fulmar, Clyde and Auk platforms.
There have also been calls for an alternative means of transport to and from
offshore installations due to the recent spate of helicopter accidents. With
some apparently calling for a combination of helicopter and ship operations,
ie a short ride from the installation by helicopter and a longer ride by
ship to a port.
Over time there have been modifications to the original “Billy Pugh” which
required one to stand on the outside of a ring, holding on grimly to rope
netting while being swung about by the crane. Now there is the Frog, which
you sit inside, slightly restrained, and the new Billy Pugh which apparently
you stand inside, lightly attached. Here we are dealing with two
diametrically opposed risks, one is that you might fall off but that you
would survive if the whole thing fell into the sea. The other is that you
won’t fall off, but probably would not survive the fall into the sea inside
INFORMATION ABOUT THIS NEWSLETTER AND SHIPS AND OIL LTD
INFORMATION ABOUT THIS NEWLETTER AND SHIPS AND OIL LTD
This newsletter expresses the views of the author Victor Gibson about marine
events which are considered to be worthy of interest. It is meant to be a
five minute read. Sources of information usually include:
International Tug and OSV Magazine
Maritime Bulletin (Now apparently no more)
The Tugs, Towing and Offshore Newsletter.
The Nautilus Telegraph
The Nautical institute Magazine Seaways
The BBC Home Page
The Somalia Report
The MAIB Website
The Ships and Oil website contains comprehensive information about many
offshore vessels and approaching 10,000 images.
My latest excuse for not updating the company information is that I have
been at work as opposed to working on the website. The website is not
financially rewarding but I am semi-retired, and so I keep at it, if for no
other reason than to share with ship enthusiasts the great photos I am sent
I read that there are more an more owners of offshore vessels appearing on
the scene. Where will they get their crews? Maybe they will get them from
the many Brazilian seafarers who send me their CVs in the hope of gaining
employment. I have emailed one or two asking why, but they either don’t know
or don’t choose to tell me.
People have continued to send pictures of the day for which I am very
grateful. I am getting into my stride again and regular updates are taking
place. The photos brighten the days of our hundreds of visitors as they sit
at their desks – I have noticed that our numbers are considerably reduced at
Recent Pictures of the Day include:
The Noble Paul Romero
The HOS Bluewater
The Global 1200
The Esvagt Server
The Don Nicola
The North Sea Giant
The Sea Cecile
The Troms Capella
SHIPS AND OIL OFFERS THE FOLLOWING PUBLICATION FOR SALE ON ITS WEBSITE:
THE HISTORY OF THE SUPPLY SHIP £37.50 inc P&P anywhere
SUPPLY SHIP OPERATIONS £27.50 inc P&P anywhere
RIGMOVES £5.75 inc P&P anywhere
SEE THE WEBSITE FOR MORE INFORMATION.
Buy all three books for the bargain price of £52.5
If you would prefer not to receive further news letters please email me email@example.com
Vic Gibson. December 2012.
If you would like to
receive News and Views as a PDF - with photos -